How To Cook a Turkey1
1with holiday tips
By Amanda Tackett
Congratulations, you’re about to cook a holiday turkey. Perhaps your first. Perhaps not.2
Either way, I’ve perfected an idiot-proof way to cook a bird. Join me in this culinary adventure.3
Ingredients:
What you will “need”:
- 1 turkey.4 (duh) (Stick with a 10-15 lb bird unless you hate your family and want leftovers until March.)
- 1 roasting pan. (If you got one for a wedding gift, measure your oven to make sure it fits.) (duh) (I recommend one of those disposable aluminum things.)5
- Water. (Don’t ask me to give you an amount, I’ll explain later.)
- A shitload of tinfoil.6
Optional:
- Browning sauce.7
- A stick of butter.8
- Salt and pepper.9
Suggested:
- Margaritas.
Directions:
Three days before you plan to eat this bitch:10 Defrost it. (duh) 11
The day before, get ready. You’re about to be a superstar. 12
The evening before the big meal, relax, have a margarita. Then, cut the plastic off the turkey, and wash it.13
At 9:30 p.m. (sharp), preheat your oven to 500 degrees. Then, have another margarita.
While you are copping a buzz, put the turkey in the roasting pan. If you want the turkey to be brown, just for aesthetic reasons, rub the skin with the browning stuff that I said was optional, otherwise skip it. If you are going to make real giblet gravy, then shove the stick of butter up the turkey’s ass. If not, skip it, and leave the turkey’s ass alone. Including the butter now will save you time tomorrow.
Now, you’re looking at a roasting pan with a dead bird in it. You’re thinking, I’m not sure I can pull this off. 14
So, here’s where you put the water in…it depends on your turkey and the pan. You want an inch of water in the bottom of the pan. An inch is about the length of the tip of your thumb. 15
Now comes the foil part. Spread out a length of foil on your counter. It needs to be long enough to center the whole turkey in the pan on the foil, cover the top, and have an inch or two to crimp it shut. Don’t scrimp. If you went horizontal the first time, go vertical the next time, or vice versa. Basically, you are going to build a big foil tent over the turkey. Keep doing this on the diagonals until the entire turkey and pan are tented and fully covered, and pinch all of the seams closed.16
At 10 p.m. Put your turkey/foil sculpture in the oven. If it’s a 10 lb turkey, you cook it for 2 hours. For a 15 lb. turkey, it’s 3, and adjust accordingly, try doing the math. So, depending on the weight of your turkey, you can watch the news, Letterman, and a cheesy re-run while you have another margarita. If you have a time cook setting on the oven, use it. Go to bed. Stop drinking. You should be ashamed of yourself. If not, you have to stay awake long enough to turn the off.
Here is the most important part of this helpful holiday cooking guide:
DO NOT OPEN THE OVEN DOOR until after 10 a.m. the next day 17
I HIGHLY RECOMMEND PUTTING A NOTE ON THE OVEN DOOR THAT SAYS, “IF YOU OPEN THIS DOOR, I WILL KILL YOU.”
At 10 a.m. the next day, take an Advil and some B vitamins for your margarita hangover. Swear under your breath that you will never drink again. Liar. Remove the turkey tent from the oven. Unwrap the foil. When you get down to the bird, you will notice it is very delicate, hence my “no ceremonial carving” recommendation. Lay out a platter or cutting board. CAREFULLY, with both hands, lift the turkey and set it on the platter or carving board. (It will be warm, but not so hot that it will burn you.) At this point, you will realize that it is so tender and juicy, it will literally fall off the bone. With your hands, you will be able to remove almost all of the meat. You can sort it between dark and light, although I just pile it up in a turkey meat free- for- all. You can discard the skin…see, that’s why you don’t need that browning stuff unless your parents are there, and they fear initially ugly food. Save the juice in the pan. This is what you will use to make gravy.
Amanda’s Commentary and Holiday Tips:
2Which means you can’t cook. Why you’ve asked me for help is a mystery. Can I suggest catering?
3Unless you are smart, and choose catering.
4Just get a cheap one. It doesn’t matter if it’s a “designer” turkey. Serve booze. No one will know the difference.
5Okay, moment of truth, the first year I made a turkey, I got an awesome 32 inch roaster as a wedding gift, and only figured out on Thanksgiving Day my oven was 28 inches wide.
6Look, you don’t want to do more dishes than are absolutely necessary. Don’t even recycle that crap. (Alternate: if your family is really annoying, use a “real” pan, don’t wash it, and they will leave by 10 a.m. Saturday, guaranteed.)
7Screw the “green” people. This is no time to worry about the environment, or aluminum residue in food. You have people coming, and they’ll be hungry. And, by the time memory loss sets in, you’ll be old, and you won’t care.
8You can get this on the grocery aisle where they sell “instant” gravy. Be advised, there will be geriatrics on this aisle. Only do this if your family has some kind of ceremonial carving thing. Otherwise, skip it. I don’t recommend ceremonial carving. You’ll understand why later.
9It’s turkey. It tastes like turkey. No matter what you do, you won’t be able to overcome that fact.
10For Thanksgiving, that’s Monday. For Christmas, that’s either the 21st or 22nd. If you buy the turkey within a week of your event, you can just stick it in the fridge. It will be okay. I would like to take this opportunity to tell you that the first time I tried to make a turkey, I didn’t defrost it. Don’t be like me. Your whole family could die. If you had my family, that’s not necessarily a bad thing. IJS.
11I’m guessing you’re young. To prevent death by salmonella, take it out of the freezer, and put it in the fridge.
12I would like to take this opportunity to say that Martha Stewart SUCKS. This ain’t brain surgery. Anyone with a staff of 50 people can make a cute wreath with crap hot glued on other crap. This turkey recipe? It’s easy. Plan your wardrobe accordingly.
13I only recommend this because I’m a little OCD. Don’t use soap. When you do this, take the plastic bag with “giblets” out of the turkey. This can be found up the turkey’s ass. True story, the first time I made a turkey, along with being not defrosted, I also left the plastic bag in the turkey with the giblets. Experts will tell you this can poison your family. I attribute any dain bramage my husband has to our first turkey. Throw away the instructions that came with the turkey. They are hard, they don’t work, and they will make you feel inferior.
14 I’m here to tell you, yes, you can. Get a hold of yourself.
15Don’t over-think this step. It’s just water.
16Tap into your inner Girl Scout. You want that bitch sealed up tight in the foil. Got it?
17 Look, I know you. You want to peek. You figure one little peek won’t hurt, right? WRONG. DON’T DO IT. The intense heat of the initial cooking period brings the meat to the core temp necessary to “roast” the meat and kill bacteria. It’s the STEAM that makes the turkey edible. If you open that door, you’ll ruin the bird, and I’m not responsible for the outcome. Remember when your mom told you not to touch the hot stove? That the boy in 7th grade with severe acne and braces would break your heart? This advice is given in that spirit.


